Plaza Wires Ltd IPO : Avoid

Plaza Wires Ltd IPO : Avoid
  • Date

    29th Sept, 2023 -04th Oct, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 51 to Rs. 54

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    277

Operating under its flagship brand “PLAZA CABLES” and home brands such as “Action Wires” (economical range) and “PCG”, Plaza Wires Ltd. (PWL) is involved in the business of manufacturing and selling wires along with selling and marketing of LT aluminum cables and fast moving electrical goods (“FMEG”). The company’s product mix includes products of different types of wires and cables, and FMEG such as electric fans, water heaters, switches, and switch gears, PVC insulated electrical tape, and PVC conduit pipe & accessories. In its prime business segment i.e. wires and cables (94.06% revenue mix in FY23), the company offers house wires, single & multicore round flexible industrial cables, and industrial cables for submersible pumps & motors up to 1.1kv grade. The company forays into arrangements with third-party manufacturers for its other wires and cable products such as LT power control cables, TV dish antenna co-axial cables, telephone & switchboard industrial cables, computer & LAN networking cables, close circuit television cables and solar cables, PVC insulated tape, and PVC conduit pipe & accessories. Presently, the company enjoys a network of 1,249 authorized dealers and distributors spread across pan India and C&F agents in Punjab. The company supplies its products, mainly in the states of Delhi, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana, Kerala, and Rajasthan. To cater to its customer requirements, the company is equipped with a manufacturing unit located at Baddi, Himachal Pradesh, which is set with a production capacity of 12,00,000 coils per annum.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Funding the capital expenditure towards setting up a new manufacturing unit for house wires, fire-resistant wires & cables, aluminum cables, and solar cables to expand the product portfolio.
  • Funding the working capital requirements of the company.
  • General corporate purposes.
Investment Rationale:

Expanding its manufacturing capabilities to target a wider customer pool

In the process of diversifying its customer base, PWL is expanding its manufacturing capacities for its existing products along with introducing additional capacities for its new product lines such as fireproof / survival wires, LT aluminum cables, and solar cables. To accomplish this, the business has purchased an additional land parcel in Himachal Pradesh, India with a composite sale value of Rs. 2,65,00,000 and has proposed to add an installed capacity of 8,37,000 coils per annum and 8,700 km per annum to its existing capacity of 12,00,000 coils per annum. Along with this, PWL is also taking measures to increase its dealer network visibility in the southern parts such as Karnataka, Telangana, Puducherry, and other states in Central and Eastern India. Additionally, it aims to deepen its penetration levels in its existing location on the northern side.

Industry tailwinds in the wires and cables industry to augment business growth

The Indian wires and cables market is valued at about Rs. 1,033 billion in FY23 and is expected to grow at a robust pace going forward. The various government initiatives is likely to boost demand, with power and infrastructure aiding demand for wires and cables, growth in fire survival cables supported by metro, airport, and commercial real estate projects, and Smart Cities Missions supporting demand for underground cables. As discussed above, the company plans to increase its production capabilities in other categories to cater to the increasing demand. Additionally, the business aims to expand its market share in key growth sectors such as mining, oil and gas, shipping, power, infrastructure, construction, automotive, telecommunication, and agriculture to slice on a larger pie of opportunities.

Valuation and Outlook:

The Indian wires and cables industry is poised to benefit from the strong growth trajectory in the residential projects post the central government’s aim of building 20 million affordable houses in urban areas across the country by 2022, under the ambitious Pradhan Mantri Awas Yojana (PMAY) scheme of the Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs. On the upper price band, the issue is valued at a P/E of 22x based on FY2023 earnings which prices in most of the positives of the company. Moreover, it is important to note that Plaza Wires Ltd. operates in an industry which has high raw material volatility (which is in an uptrend over the years). Additionally, the business operates in a highly competitive industry with multiple big players which can challenge the pricing power of the company. Thus, considering the above factors, we recommend an “Avoid” rating for the issue.

Valiant Laboratories Ltd. IPO : Subscribe

Valiant Laboratories Ltd. IPO : Subscribe
  • Date

    27th September, 2023 - 03rd October, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 133 to Rs. 140

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    105

Valiant Laboratories Ltd. is an Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient (API) / Bulk Drug manufacturing company focusing on manufacturing Paracetamol. These Bulk drugs/APIs are raw materials for manufacturing finished dosage forms or formulations. Paracetamol is one of the most commonly taken analgesics worldwide and is recommended as the first-line therapy in pain conditions by the World Health Organization. Paracetamol has several applications, such as in treating headaches, muscle aches, arthritis, backaches, toothaches, cold and fever. The company manufactures Paracetamol in various grades, such as IP/BP/EP/USP, as per the pharmacopeia requirements of customers. Paracetamol was initially approved by the USFDA in 1951 and is available in various forms, including syrup, regular, injections, and other forms. Paracetamol is often found combined with other drugs in many over-the-counter (OTC) allergy medications, cold medications, sleep medications, pain relievers, and other products. The company’s manufacturing facility is located at Plot nos. L-13 and L-30, Tarapur Industrial Area, Boisar, Palghar, in the state of Maharashtra, India, which is spread over an aggregate parcel of land admeasuring about 2,000 sq. mts. with an aggregate annual total installed capacity of 9,000 MTPA.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Investment in its wholly-owned subsidiary, Valiant Advanced Sciences Private Limited (VASPL) for part-financing its capital expenditure requirements in relation to the setting up of a manufacturing facility for specialty chemicals at Saykha Industrial Area Bharuch Gujarat (Proposed Facility);
  • Investment in VASPL for funding its working capital requirements;
  • General corporate purposes.
Investment Rationale:

Implement backward integration at planned facility to improve operational efficiency

The company intends to implement backward integration measures to improve operational efficiencies by manufacturing ketene and diketene derivative products. The company will consume one of such derivative products as a raw material, i.e. acetic anhydride, used in manufacturing paracetamol. The remaining products manufactured at the proposed facility will be sold to external customers, including agrochemical, pharma intermediary, dyes, pigments, food and fragrance industries. These backward integration measures will allow the company to gain a competitive advantage by reducing product costs, controlling the oversupply of raw materials, minimizing supply failure risk and reducing dependency on third parties. With backward integration, the company will have greater control over the manufacturing process and quality standards and benefit from cost efficiencies. As a result, Valiant expects to fulfill customer needs in a timely manner, increase sales per customer, and improve working capital and supply chain processes.

Focus on increasing penetration into overseas markets to become the ideal supplier of Paracetamol to pharma companies.

The company seeks to enhance its presence in international geographies, including regulated markets, where the strategy is primarily to become the preferred supplier of Paracetamol API to pharmaceutical companies. The company intends to obtain approvals to sell in the regulated markets. The growth strategy will vary from country to country depending on applicable regulatory norms. The company has a relationship with existing customers and would help to further strengthen the relationship with these companies. Valiant’s existing manufacturing facility at Tarapur Industrial area, Palghar, Maharashtra, operates a management system by the requirements of ISO 9001:2015. The company will also continue to evaluate additional markets and relationships, which will be beneficial to increase its presence in domestic and export markets and drive profitability.

Valuation and Outlook:

Valiant Laboratories Ltd. is an Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient / Bulk Drug manufacturing company focusing on manufacturing Paracetamol. The company manufactures Paracetamol in various grades and sizes per customers’ specifications, like powder, fine powder, dense, free flowing, etc. These grades represent different pharmacopeia standards. The company sells products through an existing set of customers and new customers. Further, the paracetamol API industry grew from Rs. 22 billion in FY17 to Rs. 39 billion in FY23, led by growth in the pain and analgesics therapy area, which focuses on the treatment of common fever, cough, and cold, as well as volume rise coupled with strong realization levels for players. The paracetamol API industry is expected to clock a CAGR of 5-7% between FY23 and FY27, primarily driven by domestic formulation manufacturers’ demand and export markets’ demand. Further, the company has a track record of sustained revenue growth, growing at a CAGR of 35.3% during FY21-23. With strong operational efficiency, Valiant Laboratories has demonstrated high ROCE, positive operating cash flows, strong balance sheet, pursued growth opportunities and better managed unanticipated cash flow variations, which will drive the company’s performance going ahead. On the upper price band, the issue is valued at a P/E of 15.7x based on FY2023 earnings, which is fairly valued compared to its peers. We, therefore, recommend an SUBSCRIBE rating for the issue.

Updater Services Ltd IPO : Avoid

Updater Services Ltd IPO : Avoid
  • Date

    25th Sept, 2023 - 27th Sept, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 280 to Rs. 300

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    50

Updater Services Ltd. was founded by Raghunandana Tangirala, who has over 30 years of experience in the integrated business services industry. The company is India’s leading, focused, integrated business services platform. It offers its customers integrated facilities management (IFM) and business support services (BSS) with a pan-India presence. Updater is India’s second-largest player in the IFM market and has the most comprehensive service offering in the industry, making it a unique and differentiated player. In their BSS segment, the company offers Audit and Assurance services through its Subsidiary, Matrix. According to the F&S Report, Matrix is a leading Audit and Assurance company for dealer/distributor audits and retail audits, and its substantial branch reach and field associate reach have driven the company to reach the top spot in India, with a market share of 19.2% in FY23. They also offer employee background verification check services through Matrix, and in this segment, Matrix is the third largest company in India, with a share of 5.4% in FY23. In addition, it provides sales enablement services through its subsidiaries, Denave and Athena. As per the F&S Report, Denave is the most significant player in this segment, with a market share of 20.1% in India in FY23. In addition, they offer mailroom management services through its subsidiary, Avon, a market leader in India with a share of 11.1% in the mailroom management services market in FY23. The company’s portfolio of services has also evolved over the years to cater to the needs of diverse customer segments across a range of sectors, including FMCG, manufacturing and engineering, banking, financial services and insurance (BFSI), healthcare, information technology/information technology-enabled services (IT / ITeS), automobiles, logistics and warehousing, airports, ports, infrastructure and retail, among others.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Repayment and /or prepayment of certain borrowings availed by the Company;
  • Funding the company’s working capital requirements;
  • Pursuing inorganic initiatives; and
  • General corporate purposes.

 

Investment Rationale:

Longstanding relationship with customers across diverse sectors leading to recurring business

Updater primarily provides IFM and other services and BSS to customers across various industries and sectors. Within the IFM & other services segment, they offer services to industries including such as healthcare, manufacturing, automobile, BFSI and consumer products, with some of its marquee customers being TTK Healthcare Limited within healthcare, Saint-Gobain within manufacturing, Hyundai, Honda Motorcycle and Eicher Motors Limited within automobile, Shriram Transport, SBI Life Insurance and IIFL Finance within BFSI, and Sony within consumer products, among others. Within the BSS segment, they offer their services to industries including retail, IT / ITeS, consumer products, global technology, IT and electronics, airlines, and telecom and communications, with some of its marquee customers being More Retail Private Limited and ABFRL within retail, TCS and Mindtree within IT / ITeS, P&G and Hershey India Private Limited (“Hershey”) within consumer products, Microsoft within global technology, Logitech (Electronics) India Private Limited within IT and electronics, SpiceJet Limited (“SpiceJet”) and AIX Connect Private Limited (“AIX Connect”) within airlines sector and Tata Communications within telecom and communications. Such a diverse base of customers has allowed the company to reduce its vulnerabilities to economic cycles and dependence on any particular set of customers.

Track record of successful acquisition and integration of high-margin business segments

The company has established a track record of successful inorganic growth through strategic acquisitions to supplement its business segments, diversify its revenue streams, and further integrate such acquired businesses to strengthen its services portfolio. Their acquisitions have added a new customer segment, service line, or geography. Their acquisition of Avon Solutions and Logistics Private Ltd. allowed them to provide mailroom management services, logistics consulting, asset movement and niche logistics services customised to the specific requirements of its customers. The company’s acquisition of Matrix Business Services Private Limited added critical services for them, such as employee background verification check services and Audit and Assurance services to its portfolio. Through Washroom Hygiene Concept Private Ltd.’s acquisition, they provide feminine hygiene care solutions and products and services such as air fresheners, sanitisers and washroom solutions such as sanitiser dispensers and refills, surface sanitising system services, vending and utility machines, hand hygiene system and solutions, amongst others. Updater has historically introduced operating efficiencies and revenue growth and has increased the profitability of its acquired businesses, resulting in increased operating margins on a consolidated level.

Valuation and Outlook:

The global Facility Management (FM) market is witnessing a significant transformation driven by technology innovation, new business models, emerging value propositions, competitive disruption, and new service offerings as value propositions shift to service outcomes, user experience, and business productivity. Outsourcing is evolving rapidly worldwide; in the past decade, the main objective of outsourcing was cost optimisation, but today, organisations want to outsource FM services to free up internal resources to deliver strategic value. The IFM market in India has been growing steadily over the last decade and is set to witness significant growth momentum over the next five years. The total IFM market in India in the Financial Year ended March 31, 2023, is valued at Rs. 100,386.7 crores and around 39.3% of this is outsourced to third-party companies. Between FY18 and FY23, the outsourced Indian IFM market grew at a CAGR of 9.5%. The demand for IFM services has increased as people’s preferences for a safe, clean, and secure environment have grown. Over the years, Updater has become a pan-India player, with a widespread network consisting of 4,331 locations (excluding staffing locations) managed from 129 points of presence with 116 offices in India and 13 overseas offices as of June 30, 2023. The company’s widespread network enables it to service many customers and render customised services across India, where they are required to provide services per the customer’s specific needs through a combination of workforce, materials, supervision, technology and economic models. Their contracts with most of its customers are for at least one year, which subsequently gets renewed on an ongoing basis. As a result, their business is on an annuity-based model where a customer, once secured, generates revenue over a long period. If we attribute FY23 earnings to the post-IPO fully diluted paid-up equity capital of the company, the asking price is at a P/E of 44.8x, and we believe it to be priced aggressively. We, therefore, recommend an “Avoid” rating for the issue. However, we would reassess the company on improvement in financial metrics over a sustained period.

JSW Infrastructure Ltd. IPO : Subscribe

JSW Infrastructure Ltd. IPO : Subscribe
  • Date

    25th September, 2023 - 27thSeptember, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 113 to Rs. 119

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    28

JSW Infrastructure Ltd., a part of JSW Group, is the fastest-growing port-related infrastructure company that provides maritime-related services including cargo handling storage solutions, logistics services, and other value-added services to its customers which is also evolving into an end-to-end logistics solutions provider. The company develops and operates ports and port terminals pursuant to port concessions which typically have long concession periods ranging between 30 to 50 years. The company has a diversified presence across India with non-major ports located in Maharashtra and port terminals located at major ports across the industrial regions of Goa and Karnataka on the west coast, and Odisha and Tamil Nadu on the east coast. In addition to partnering with its JSW Group customers (Related Parties), the company has a customer base that includes third-party customers across geographies. With India being positioned to be one of the fastest-growing major economies in terms of GDP between Fiscal 2024 and 2026, the company intends to capitalize on this strong growth momentum by broadening its cargo profile, expanding its geographical presence, and diversifying its revenue streams. The company proposes to achieve this by leveraging its experience in developing and acquiring assets across geographies and catering to diverse cargo types.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Prepayment or repayment, in full or part, of all or a portion of certain outstanding borrowings through investment in its wholly owned subsidiaries, JSW Dharamtar Port Private Limited and JSW Jaigarh Port Limited;
  • Financing capital expenditure requirements through investment in its wholly owned subsidiary, JSW Jaigarh Port Limited, for proposed expansion/upgradation works at Jaigarh Port i.e, i) expansion of LPG terminal (“LPG Terminal Project”); ii) setting up an electric sub-station; and iii) purchase and installation of dredger;
  • Financing capital expenditure requirements through investment in its wholly owned subsidiary, JSW Mangalore Container Terminal Private Limited, for proposed expansion at Mangalore Container Terminal (“Mangalore Container Project”); and
  •  General corporate purposes.
Investment Rationale:

Fastest-growing port-related infrastructure company and second-largest commercial port operator in India

JSW Infrastructure Ltd. is the second largest commercial port operator in India and operates in an industry that has several entry barriers. The company is also the fastest-growing port-related infrastructure company in terms of growth in installed cargo handling capacity and cargo volumes handled from Fiscal 2021 to Fiscal 2023. The company’s installed cargo handling capacity in India grew at a CAGR of 15.3% between March 31, 2021, and March 31, 2023, and the volume of cargo handled in India also grew at a CAGR of 42.8% from Fiscal 2021 to Fiscal 2023. The company operates nine port concessions in India with an installed cargo handling capacity of 158.43 MTPA as of June 30, 2023, and its position in the Indian maritime infrastructure industry enables it to leverage economies of scale in project development capabilities and resource optimization. Based on the expertise the company has developed over the years, the company is able to provide a wide range of maritime services and cater to its customers’ diverse cargo needs across key locations, which is difficult to replicate and creates significant barriers for new entrants.

Strategically located assets in close proximity to JSW Group customers and industrial cluster.

Location plays a major differentiator in the ports industry. Ports that are closer to major shipping routes enjoy a competitive advantage as shipping from those ports translate into cost savings for importers and exporters. The company’s port concessions are strategically located on the west and east coasts of India and are well connected to its customers including JSW Group customers (Related Parties) located in the industrial hinterlands of Maharashtra, Goa, Karnataka, Tamil Nadu ,Andhra Pradesh, and Telangana, and mineral-rich belts of Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand and Odisha. These states manage large volumes of cargo from coastal areas and the broader hinterland. The location of the company’s assets helps them to provide end-to-end logistics services as they are connected to cargo origination as well as cargo consumption points.

Valuation and Outlook:

India is positioned to be one of the fastest growing major economies and is expected to log an annual average economic growth of 6.6% between Fiscal 2024 and Fiscal 2026. A stronger domestic demand is expected to drive India’s growth premium over peers in the medium term. The investment prospects in India are bright, given the government’s capital expenditure push, the rapid progress of the Production linked Incentive (“PLI”) scheme, healthier corporate balance sheets, and a well-capitalized banking sector with low non-performing assets. India is poised to become a USD 5 trillion economy and ports would play a significant role in the growth story. Straddling the Bay of Bengal, the Indian Ocean, and the Arabian Sea with a coastline of approximately 7,517 km, the Indian economy occupies a commercially enviable location on the global map. Ports in India handle 90% by volume and 70% by value of India’s external trade. The maritime route is used to import crude petroleum, iron ore, coal, and other critical goods. The company is involved in the business of developing and managing ports, and provides maritime-related services including cargo handling storage solutions, logistics services, and other value-added services to its customers. Being in a capital-intensive business requiring huge capital as well as years of experience, JSW Infrastructure Ltd. looks well-positioned to maintain its dominant position in the ports industry in India in terms of cargo handling capacity and cargo volumes handled. The company also enjoys a strong parentage of JSW Group which has presence in various sectors in India and offers customer stickiness in the long term. The company also has plans to undertake various greenfield and brownfield expansions in the coming years which would prove beneficial for the business performance going forward. The company has a track record of sustained Revenue/EBITDA/PAT performance which grew at a CAGR of 41.2%/42.1%/62.3% during FY2021-23 period. On the upper price band, the issue is valued at a P/E of 29.7x based on FY2023 earnings which we feel is fairly valued. We, therefore, recommend a “Subscribe” rating for the issue.

Manoj Vaibhav Gems ‘N’ Jewellers Ltd IPO : Subscribe

Manoj Vaibhav Gems ‘N’ Jewellers Ltd IPO : Subscribe
  • Date

    22nd Sept, 2023 - 24th Sept, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 204 to Rs. 215

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    69

Incorporated in 2003, Manoj Vaibhav Gems ‘N’ Jewellers Ltd. (MVGJL) is a very strong and well-entrenched jewellery brand in South India and also goes under the brand of Vaibhav Jewellers. It is a hyperlocal jewellery retail chain with a presence in the micro markets of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana with 13 showrooms (inclusive of two franchisee showrooms) across 8 towns and 2 cities. It has a market share of ~4% of the overall Andhra Pradesh and Telangana jewellery market and ~10% of the organized market in these two states in FY23. MVGJL is one of the early entrants in the organized jewellery retail market of Andhra Pradesh and continues to focus on the high-growth untapped regions within the micro-markets of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana. Manoj Vaibhav Gems ‘N’ Jewellers Ltd. offers gold, silver, and diamond jewellery in different traditional and modern designs for its customers categorized between 5 classes according to the occasion and price range. The Daily-wear Jewellery is plain gold with no stone studding and is preferred for daily use. The second is Bridal Jewellery which offers a wide choice of jewellery for women for the big occasion. Thirdly, the Occasion Wear Jewellery is an extension of bridal jewellery and can be segregated for functions like Mehandi, Sangeet, Roka, etc. Fourthly, there is antique jewellery with fairly elaborate and ethnic workmanship that is used for the relic look. Lastly, there is the unique classification of Temple Jewellery, which is again based on classic workmanship with each piece curated and handmade.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Funding capital expenditure towards setting up of the eight new stores;
  • Funding inventory for the eight new stores;
  • General corporate purposes. 
Investment Rationale:

Stronghold in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana region.

MVGVL was amongst the first movers in the organised jewellery business in the state of Andhra Pradesh by starting the business as a proprietorship concern in the year 1994 from its first showroom in Visakhapatnam. They continue to focus on regional expansion into high-growth untapped regions within the micro-markets of Andhra Pradesh & Telangana. The company has a market share of ~4% of the overall Andhra Pradesh and Telangana jewellery market and ~10% of the organised market in these two states in FY23. The product range and offerings have allowed MVGJL to cater to all customer segments and genres, thus augmenting its brand strength and building a loyal customer base. Over the years, they have catered to the needs and changing trends of the market and strived to give the best and premium level of shopping experience to customers through their retail showrooms. Before opening any retail showroom, the company conducts a thorough study of the market and surroundings, maps the choice and preference of consumers, studies the reach and the type of localities and does an estimate of all parameters to ensure that business from that retail showroom will result into positive growth for the company.

Excellent marketing strategies and focus on rural markets

Over the years, MVGJL has invested substantial effort in building its brand. This includes various forms of promotion and marketing activities, engaging with brand ambassadors, organizing exhibitions and being part of conferences. In the past, the company has engaged with brand ambassadors such as Rakul Preet Singh, Kajal Agarwal, and Priya Anand to boost the presence of the brand and have a wider reach. One of MVGJL’s unique proposition is creating an inventory of varied designs and products. This approach of the company ensures repeat customers seeking varied types of designs and products as it has a wide range of options in various categories, price ranges and occasions. The company connects with target groups through exhibitions to understand the tastes and preferences of the customers through its “Go to Marketing Strategy”. Rural markets have a larger pie of the retail jewellery market and the inelasticity of rural demand for gold offers large potential for growth. 77% of MVGJL’s retail showrooms are in Tier 2 and Tier 3 cities, catering to the semi-urban and rural demand of Andhra Pradesh and Telangana. The remaining retail showrooms are located in Hyderabad and Visakhapatnam, catering to the urban consumers. MVGJL follows a hub and spoke model with small-sized showrooms operating peripheral to the larger showrooms. This allows it to offer new products to semi-urban and rural customers on a continuous basis and capture a share of that market.

Valuation and Outlook:

The total jewellery market in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana is expected to grow at a CAGR of ~18% during FY2023-27 period to reach Rs. 96,500 crores by FY27. MVGJL has positioned itself well to capture a good chunk of this growth by catering to all economic segments and micro markets in Andhra Pradesh and Telangana through branded showrooms with a strong focus on the rural market and a dedicated urban focus. The company has displayed steady growth in revenue and even more robust profit growth which is up more than three-fold in two years. MVGJL boasts of a 23% return on its equity in FY23 which is attractive compared to its peers. They plan to open eight new stores to target more Tier 2 and Tier 3 markets which augurs well as rural markets contributed 50-52% of the total jewellery market in FY23. The nature of the business is such that a lot of costs are front-ended but once they are mitigated, profits can grow rapidly in coming years. The company has also maintained an asset turnover ratio of 1.8x and above which is a good sign for a constantly expanding business. We believe that the company looks poised to capture a further share of the unorganized jewellery market, especially in the rural areas. Based on the prospects of the sector, the company’s product catalogue, its stronghold in the southern markets and a good track record, the pricing looks attractive vis-à-vis its peers as it values MVGJL at 11.7x of its FY23 earnings. We, therefore, recommend a SUBSCRIBE rating to the issue.

Sai Silks (Kalamandir) Ltd IPO : Subscribe

Sai Silks (Kalamandir) Ltd IPO : Subscribe
  • Date

    20th Sept, 2023 - 22nd Sept, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 210 to Rs. 222

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    67

Sai Silks (Kalamandir) Limited (SSKL) is among the top 10 retailers of ethnic apparel, particularly sarees, in south India in terms of revenues and profit after tax in Fiscal 2020, 2021, and 2022. Sai Silks (Kalamandir) currently offers a range of ultra-premium and premium sarees ideal for weddings, parties, and daily wear. It sells its apparel products through four different format stores that constitute the front end of the company’s marketing. The first store format is the Kalamandir wherein it offers contemporary ethnic fashion for the middle-income groups. These include varieties of sarees such as Tusser, Silk, Kota, Kora, Khadi, Georgette, Cotton, etc. The second format store is Vara Mahalakshmi Silks. Under this format, it offers premium ethnic silk sarees and handlooms for wedding and special occasion wear. These include Banarasi, Patola, Kota, Kanchipuram, Paithani, and Organza. The third format store is the Mandir. Under this format, the company offers very high-end and ultra-premium designer sarees targeting wealthy customers. These include designer sarees such as Banarasi, Patola, Ikat, Kanchipuram, Paithani, and Kuppadam. Finally, the fourth type of format store is the KLM Fashion Mall. This format offers value fashion at affordable prices. These include fusion wear, sarees for daily wear, and western wear for women, men, and children. It has an omnichannel approach and sells its products through physical store formats and through e-commerce channels. It has a dedicated website and also markets through online e-commerce marketplaces. As of July 2023, Sai Silks (Kalamandir) had more than 54 stores in the four south Indian states of Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Karnataka, and Tamil Nadu. Its stores cover an aggregate area of approximately 603,414 square feet.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Funding capital expenditure towards setting-up of 30 new stores and two warehouses;
  • Funding working capital requirements of the company;
  • Repayment or pre-payment, in full or part, of certain borrowings availed by the       company;
  •  General corporate purposes. 
Investment Rationale:

Well-positioned to leverage growth in the ethnic and value-fashion apparel industry with an omnichannel network.

SSKL focuses on spreading India’s vibrant culture, traditions, and heritage through its ethnic wear brands. It considers its business model to be scalable and efficient and it generally achieves immediate positive cash flow for its new format stores and achieves break even for capital expenditure incurred for setting up the exclusive format store within a reasonable period from store opening, depending on the store format. SSKL has expanded its presence in online e-commerce marketplace and started selling its products through its own online websites as well as through other third-party online e-commerce websites which provide an omnichannel network to its customers through its online and offline channels. As the pricing of its products is mostly uniform across its own online and offline channels, its customers have the flexibility to purchase its products online or offline through stores. Its increased focus towards e-commerce has expanded the reach of its products and in Fiscal 2023, its sarees were shipped to 25 states and six union territories in India.

Experienced management, a track record of profitable growth, and an efficient operating model

SSKL has a committed and large senior management team, led by its Managing Director, Nagakanaka Durga Prasad Chalavadi, who has extensive experience in the retail and fashion industry, which positions it well to capitalize on future growth opportunities. Its key managerial personnel, assisted by their teams, have been able to create a curated list of SKUs that have enhanced its brand appeal and continual improvement to its stores has enhanced the shopping experience of its customers. The company has organically grown its operations and has demonstrated increasing revenues (Rs 67.72 crores in FY21 to Rs 135.15 crores in FY23) and profitability on the back of a business model that has resulted in positive cash flows over the years, other than the year that witnessed the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic with prolonged shutdowns. SSKL also has a focused marketing strategy and has engaged popular South Indian actors as its brand ambassadors. Its focus on quality products, variety of products, customer-oriented policies together with its celebrity endorsements have enabled it to develop strong brand recognition and customer loyalty.

Valuation and Outlook:

The Indian apparel market is expected to grow at a CAGR of 21% between FY22 and FY27 on the back of factors like higher brand consciousness, increasing digitization, greater purchasing power and increasing urbanization. The growth of both branded apparel share and organized apparel retail share in the apparel category is expected to outpace the overall category growth. The COVID-19 pandemic gave an impetus to the growth of e-commerce which is expected to become a significant growth driver for the organized market. Sai Silks (Kalamandir) Limited, being a leading brand in South India, has shown strong topline growth in the last two years, displaying the true potential of ethnic wear retailing in India. The company intends to continue its cluster-based expansion model and increase its presence across southern India in order to ensure better operational control over its stores. The company’s focus on creating a differentiated shopping experience for various needs and segments of customers through its different format stores as well as the dedicated online portal has been a key factor in increasing the average business per customer and word-of-mouth references. In the retail business where margins are often in single digits and under pressure, SSKL has displayed excellent growth in profit and EBITDA margins. The company also has a high return on equity of around 28% which is likely to sustain the stock at high valuations. For a capital-intensive business, SSKL has also maintained an impressive asset turnover ratio of 1.1x which will give much-needed confidence to the company as it embarks on a massive expansion. On the upper price band, the issue is valued at a P/E of 27x based on FY2023 earnings which is lower compared to its peers and is reasonable for the retail business where the valuation matrix should only get better from hereon. We, therefore, recommend a SUBSCRIBE rating for the issue.

Signature Global (India) Ltd IPO : Avoid

Signature Global (India) Ltd IPO : Avoid
  • Date

    20th Sept, 2023 - 22nd Sept, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 366 to Rs. 385

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    38

Signature Global (India) Ltd. is one of the largest real estate development companies in the Delhi NCR region in the affordable and lower mid-segment housing in terms of units supplied (in the below Rs. 8 million price category) between 2020 and the three months ended March 31, 2023, with a market share of 19%. The company has strategically focused on the Affordable Housing (AH) segment (below Rs. 4 million price category) and the Middle Income Housing (MH) segment (between Rs. 4 million to Rs. 25 million private category) through the central government and state government policies. Most of the company’s completed projects, ongoing projects and forthcoming projects are located in Gurugram and Sohna in Haryana, with 88.5% of their saleable area located in this region as of March 31, 2023, and almost all of their projects have been, or are being, undertaken under the AHP (Affordable Housing Policy) or the DDJAY – APHP (Affordable Plotted Housing Policy or the Deen Dayal Jan Awas Yojana). In FY23, they completed an aggregate developable area of 7.64 million square feet in the completed projects and an additional 1.37 million square feet in its ongoing projects, comprising 11,427 residential and 932 commercial units, for which the company has received occupation certificates. The company has adopted an integrated real estate development model, with in-house capabilities and resources to execute projects from inception to completion, enabling it to offer competitive prices. They can efficiently turn around projects on land that they tie up, and they have typically launched projects within 18 months from the land’s acquisition date.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Re-payment or pre-payment, in whole or in part, of certain borrowings availed by the company;
  • Infusion of funds in certain of their subsidiaries, namely Signature Global Homes, Signature Infrabuild, Signature Global Developers, and Sternal Buildcon, for re-payment or pre-payment, in whole or in part, of certain borrowings availed by their subsidiaries;
  • Inorganic growth through land acquisitions and general corporate purposes.

 

Investment Rationale:

One of the leading affordable and lower-mid and mid-segment real estate developers in Delhi NCR and Haryana.

Signature Global is one of the largest real estate development companies in Delhi NCR in affordable and lower mid-segment housing, in terms of units supplied in Gurugram (in the below Rs. 8 million price category) between 2020 and the three months ended March 31, 2023, they had a market share of 31% (Source: Anarock Report). The company has focused on the affordable and lower mid segments in Delhi NCR, which have significant demand. All their projects are located in Delhi NCR, considered among India’s top two markets in sales in the three months ending March 31, 2023. They are one of the largest real estate developers under the AHP in the Gurugram and Sohna region, with a market share of 18% in total supply of units from 2020 to the three months that ended March 31, 2023. In addition to multiple projects in Gurugram, they have also selectively expanded in rapidly growing towns in Delhi NCR in the vicinity of Gurugram, including Karnal and Manesar in Haryana, as well as in Raj Nagar Extension, Ghaziabad in Uttar Pradesh. The company is well-positioned to capitalise on the significant demand for affordable housing projects in these micro-markets.

Standardised product offerings, quick turnaround, and end-to-end in-house project execution expertise.

With years of experience, the company has implemented standardised business processes that have enabled it to offer quality houses at competitive prices to its customers. Signature Global has achieved low design costs and efficiencies, a relatively short development cycle, and construction timelines due to its standardised design, technical specifications, and layout plans. In the seven AHP projects involving 5,338 residential units they have launched between FY21 and FY23, they have undertaken negligible variation in the sizes and configurations of the units. The company has typically completed projects within 18 months of land acquisition. Their turnaround capabilities have enabled their land resources to generate cash flows relatively quickly following acquisition to support further developments.

Valuation and Outlook:

The demographic shift has positively impacted the demand for residential real estate, and urbanisation has further contributed to the need for housing in urban areas. The government’s policy support, supportive intervention, and increased household income have improved affordability in the last two and a half decades. The rise in household income with almost steady ticket price levels has increased the affordability of housing units. While many locations in the NCR region can be identified as affordable housing destinations, the Gurugram-Sohna region collectively accounted for a large share of the affordable units supplied in NCR (98% for 2022 and 84% for the first quarter of 2023). Post-COVID-19, the demand for individual floors (builder floors) has increased and is likely to witness considerable demand and absorption in coming years. Signature Global is expected to benefit from these industry tailwinds as it has an established distribution network targeting affordable and mid-segment customers. The company has a dedicated in-house direct sales team responsible for sourcing leads. The company has a track record in execution and continued construction that has been instrumental in its consistent sales and performance despite challenging market conditions due to the COVID-19 pandemic. They have generated positive operating cash flows despite incurring significant business development expenses for growth and without significantly increasing the leverage. Though the company has a good market share in its focused regions, its continued losses in the last three financial years make us cautious about the IPO. We, therefore, recommend an “Avoid” rating for the issue. 

Yatra Online Ltd IPO : Subscribe

Yatra Online Ltd IPO : Subscribe
  • Date

    15th Sept, 2023 - 20th Sept, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 135 to Rs.142

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    105

Yatra Online is India’s leading corporate travel services provider in terms of the number of corporate clients and the third largest online travel company in India among key OTA players in gross booking revenue and operating revenue for FY23. The company has the most significant hotel and accommodation tie-ups amongst key domestic OTA players of over 21,05,600 as of March 31, 2023. Yatra Online is also India’s leading corporate travel service provider with 813 large corporate customers, over 49,800 registered SME customers, and the third largest consumer online travel company (OTC) in the country in gross booking revenue for FY23. Further, the company’s go-to-market strategy spans the entire travel and hospitality value chain, covering B2B and B2C models. The combination of B2B and B2C channels enables the company to cost-effectively target India’s most frequent and high-spending travellers, namely, educated urban consumers. In addition, the Yatra travel agent network provides additional scale to business by leveraging an integrated technology platform to aggregate consumer demand from over 29,800 travel agents in over 1,000 cities across India as of March 31, 2023.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Strategic investments, acquisitions, and inorganic growth.
  • Investment in customer acquisition and retention, technology, and other organic growth initiatives.
  • General Corporate Purposes. 

 

Investment Rationale:

Strong brand recognition with a proven track record & focus on marketing strategy

Yatra Online is a leading full-service online travel company in India and one of the well-recognized travel brands in the country, addressing the needs of both leisure and business travellers. The company believes that the leading market position and operational history have led to a wide scale recognition of the Yatra brand in India, which enables the company to target new customers coming into the category and also helps to provide better leverage when contracting with airlines and hotel suppliers. To further strengthen the brand, the company has occasionally signed up some of India’s leading celebrities as brand ambassadors. The company has also invested in developing and promoting the brand since its inception, using online, offline, cross-marketing, social media and other marketing initiatives. The company has allied with various brands for cross-marketing products and services. With a focus on marketing strategies, the company has increased brand awareness, driven potential customers to platforms and improved the rate at which visitors become customers.

Long-standing relationships with key customers to sustain growth

Yatra Online has served over 14 million cumulative travel customers as of March 31, 2023, with over half of them signing up for the eCash loyalty program. The company websites and mobile applications are designed to give customers flexibility in choosing travel options. The company recorded a booking success rate of 97.8% on websites and mobile applications in the B2C channel for domestic transactions during FY23. The company is dedicated to ensuring a superior user experience on the platform and is critical to customer service. The company provide customer support in all stages of customer trips; before, during and after. Yatra chat system is an essential communication between buyers and sellers, buyers and customer service and sellers and seller support. The company monitors customer feedback using an in-house CRM system that helps to provide simple, tailor-made tools to provide rapid and effective support. In the corporate travel business, Yatra has served over 800 large corporate customers, where the customer retention rate with corporate accounts has improved from 97% in FY21 to 98% in FY22 and remains consistent in FY23, i.e., 98%. The corporate business is a platform that allows leveraging robust and long-standing relationships with corporate customers to cross-sell other products such as expense management and freight management.

Valuation and Outlook:

Yatra Online offers a comprehensive range of travel and travel-related products and services catering to the needs of passengers travelling domestically, as well as travelling to and from international destinations. The company provide customers with various tools and information that they need to research, plan, book and purchase travel products and services in India as well as outside India. With these services, the company has built and maintains strong relationships across a portfolio of suppliers for airlines, hotels and holiday packages. Further, the Indian travel industry is expected to grow at a 9-11% CAGR during FY23-28 period to reach Rs 4,540 billion in FY28, driven by the development of tourism infrastructure, rising income levels translating into higher discretionary spending on travel and tourism, and an increase in the frequency of travel for business and leisure purposes. Being one of the key players, Yatra Online is well-positioned to capture a significant share of growth in the tourism industry in India, owing to its longstanding relationship with both B2B and B2C customers. This enables the company to target India’s most frequent and high-spending travellers and educated urban consumers. With the growth in the tourism industry, we expect the online travel market share (OTA) to increase faster than captive players, improving the company’s profitability. With the company posting profits in FY23 and strong revenue growth in the past, we remain positive on the company from a medium to long-term perspective. We, therefore, recommend an SUBSCRIBE rating for the issue.

Zaggle Prepaid Ocean Services Ltd : Subscribe

Zaggle Prepaid Ocean Services Ltd : Subscribe
  • Date

    14th Sept, 2023 - 18th Sept, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 156 to Rs. 164

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    90

Zaggle Prepaid Ocean Services Limited (Zaggle) is a Hyderabad-based uniquely positioned player with a diversified offering of fintech products and services. The company has one of India’s largest issued prepaid cards in partnership with certain banking partners, a diversified portfolio of SaaS, including tax and payroll software, and a broad reach. The company is a leading player in spend management, with over 50 million prepaid cards issued in partnership with banking partners and more than 2.27 million users served as of March 31, 2023. Zaggle is a sector-agnostic company covering a network of corporate customers from the banking and finance, technology, healthcare, manufacturing, FMCG, infrastructure, and automobile sectors. The company has relationships with brands such as TATA Steel, Persistent Systems, Vitech, Inox, Pitney Bowes, Wockhardt, MAZDA, PCBL (RP – Sanjiv Goenka Group), Hiranandani Group, Cotiviti, and Greenply Industries. Zaggle offers an ecosystem-based approach across SaaS and fintech, with low customer acquisition and retention costs in the business-to-business (B2B) segment. Zaggle has collaborated with key banking partners, including IndusInd Bank, Yes Bank, and NSDL Payments Bank, and has issued over 50 million co-branded prepaid cards since the business’s inception. Zaggle’s core product portfolio includes ‘Propel’, a corporate SaaS platform for channel rewards and incentives, employee rewards and recognition; ‘Save’, a SaaS-based platform and a mobile application to offer expense management solutions for business spend management facilitating digitized employee reimbursements and tax benefits; ‘CEMS’, a customer engagement management system that enables merchants to comprehensively manage their customer experiences including rewarding merchants through gift cards and loyalty benefits; ‘Zaggle Payroll Card’, a prepaid payroll card that allows customers to pay contractors, consultants, seasonal and temporary employees, and unbanked wage workers as an alternative to direct deposits to bank accounts or cash payments; and ‘Zoyer’, an integrated data-driven, SaaS-based business spend management platform with embedded automated finance capabilities in core invoice-to-pay workflows.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Expenditure towards customer acquisition and retention. 
  • Expenditure towards the development of technology and products.
  • Repayment or prepayment of certain borrowings, in full or part, availed by the company.
  • General corporate purposes. 

 

Investment Rationale:

Differentiated SaaS-based fintech platform, offering a combination of payment instruments, mobile applications and API integrations.

Zaggle offers SaaS-based products (comprising Propel, Save, CEMS, and Zoyer) for businesses, including business and employee spend management, employee benefits management, employee incentives, channel rewards and incentives, employee rewards and recognition, and employee tax benefits. The company combines its unified SaaS-based platform with a comprehensive product stack that digitizes business and employee spend management and rewards for businesses, along with offering payment instruments such as the Zaggle Payroll Card,  Kuber Gift Card (a gift card that works both online and offline outlets where Visa cards are accepted in India) and Zinger Multi-wallet Card (a reloadable card with multiple wallets that works at both online and offline outlets where Visa cards are accepted in India). Their mobile application gives its customers and users a real-time view of card details, account balance, transactions (including transfers to bank accounts), card security, and easy expense management by allowing bills to be uploaded, approved, and paid for corporate spending and other benefits. Furthermore, API integrations (which are hosted through the cloud) with their banking partners, card networks, and merchants provide them with access to their user base.

Leveraging strategic partnerships with financial institutions and merchants

Zaggle’s partnerships are categorized into two broad categories: (i) growth and (ii) Value-added Services (VAS). To drive growth, they have partnered with industry participants and financial institutions such as DBS Bank and Razorpay, who offer their customers their products ‘Save’, ‘Propel’, and ‘Zoyer’. The company intends to leverage the insights of its partners to provide and build new solutions for its customers and users while acquiring new customers, merchants, and users with the support of its partners, including the development of new technologies and ideas. They also have VAS partnerships for services such as insurance, investment, and tax planning. For example, they have tied up with Tata Securities to market their products and to provide its users with access to investment products. In addition to using their own sales and marketing teams, they plan to leverage their partner networks while adding new partners to explore additional go-to-market opportunities and grow their customer base. The company has partnered with Fibe (formerly EarlySalary) to market its loan products to its user base. Going forward, they also intend to enable their Preferred Banking Partners to penetrate large and small businesses, attracting a wider customer base that allows them to cross-sell their offerings.

Valuation and Outlook:

India’s fintech ecosystem has approximately 2,100 start-ups spread across a wide range of segments such as payments, lending, wealthtech, insurtech, and neo-banking. India’s fintech market revenue is estimated to reach approximately Rs. 8,341 billion in 2027 from Rs. 3,123 billion in 2022 as a result of supportive government policies, rising investments, and a fintech adoption rate of approximately 87%, the highest compared to other countries. The high initial costs incurred towards spend management solution setup are also major hindrances towards market growth, giving opportunities for SaaS offerings. India’s outsourced spend management software and services market is estimated to grow from Rs. 35 billion in 2022 to Rs. 72 billion by 2027 on the back of greater awareness and higher acceptance within MSMEs coupled with the expansion of the industrial economy and increased availability of customized spend management solutions. Zaggle has created a market niche in India by offering a combined solution for spend management (through payment instruments) and employee management (through SaaS). This diversification acts as a barrier to new entrants as the combined exposure adds complexity not only in processes and offerings but also in terms of guidelines adherence and internal operations. The company demonstrated growth at a CAGR of approximately 51.9% during the three years between FY2021 and FY2023, driven by increased usage of digital modes of payment during this period in India. If we attribute FY23 earnings to the post-IPO fully diluted paid-up equity capital of the company, the asking price is at a P/E of 66.7 and we believe it to be priced aggressively. We, therefore, recommend an “Avoid” rating for the issue. However, we would reassess the company on improvement in financial metrics over a sustained period. 

Samhi Hotels Ltd : Avoid

Samhi Hotels Ltd : Avoid
  • Date

    14th Sept, 2023 - 18th Sept, 2023

  • Price Range

    Rs. 119 to Rs. 126

  • Minimum Order Quantity

    119

Incorporated in 2010, Samhi Hotels Ltd. is engaged in hotel ownership and asset management and enjoys having the third-largest inventory of operational keys (owned and leased) in India’s key urban consumption centers. As of March 31, 2023, the business portfolio includes 3,839 keys across 25 operating hotels in 12 cities. Of these 25 operational hotels, 23 are managed by third-party operators – Marriott manages 11 hotels, Hyatt manages two, and IHG manages 10. Completing the ACIC acquisition will further enhance its portfolio to reach 4,801 keys across 31 operating hotels. The company has segmented its hotel portfolio into three distinct hotel segments based on brand classification – Upper Upscale and Upscale (47.35% revenue mix), Upper Mid-scale (32.18% revenue mix), and Mid-scale (18.96% revenue mix). Apart from this, the company has a growth pipeline to add two additional hotels by adding 617 keys in existing cities and two new cities- Kolkata, West Bengal, and Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra to its demographic reach.

Objects of the issue:

The net proceeds from the fresh issue will be used towards the following purposes:

  • Repayment / prepayment / redemption, in full or in part, of certain borrowings availed of by the company and the subsidiaries including payment of the interest accrued thereon.
  • General corporate purposes.
Investment Rationale:

Favourable industry tailwinds augur well for operational metrics .

The company has strategically selected its hotels in 12 cities in India, contributing to around 70% of air passenger traffic and approximately 90% of office space in India. This allows them to enjoy higher barriers to entry due to land acquisition complexities, extended development time frames, and fragmented ownership structures. In FY23, the company’s average cost per key remained below the domestic industrial average in all three categories, i.e. Upper Upscale and Upscale (Rs. 11.96 million v/s industrial average of Rs. 12-18 million), Upper Mid-scale (Rs. 5.73 million v/s industrial average of Rs. 7-9 million) and Mid-scale (Rs. 2.36 million v/s industrial average of Rs. 5-7 million). The shift from a low base and high supply market during the FY2008-13 period to a large base with stable supply has allowed the business to command higher ARR (Average room rate) growth, leading to an improvement in its RevPAR as well. This can be evidenced by the company posting growth in its ARR for its Upper Upscale and Upscale, Upper Mid-scale and Mid-scale portfolios by 37.3%, 29.5%, and 19.7%, respectively, for the period between Q1FY23 and Q4FY23.

ACIC acquisition to drive synergetic benefits going ahead

As of March 31, 2023, the company entered into a purchase agreement with Asiya Capital to acquire nine SPVs incorporated in India comprising the ACIC portfolio, which included six operating hotels with 962 keys in the Upper Mid-Scale segment. Additionally, it had a parcel of land for developing a hotel under the Upper Mid-scale segment in Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra. Through this acquisition, the business aims to improve market presence in its existing network of cities like Hyderabad (Telangana), Pune (Maharashtra), Chennai (Tamil Nadu) and Ahmedabad (Gujarat) and create identity in new cities such as Jaipur (Rajasthan) and Mumbai (Maharashtra). Along with this, the business expanded its market share in its Marriott-branded Upper Mid-scale hotels in India to 43.5%, thus allowing it to enhance revenue management and cost efficiencies in this cluster, which will likely improve the margin profile.

Valuation and Outlook:

The Indian travel and tourism industry is slated to grow at a healthy pace over the next few years, driven by the benefits of rapid urbanization, expansion of the office market, increasing domestic travel, and initiatives from the government. Additionally, the industry is in the supply growth stabilization phase, which is likely to benefit companies like Samhi Hotels through its inherently large scale of keys and ability to expand its inventory compared to other small players in the market. While the industry tailwinds paint a rosy picture for the business, the company-specific characteristics such as loss-making status and negative net worth for the past three fiscals – FY21, FY22, and FY23 paint an overall bleak picture for the business compared to improvement in metrics of its listed peers like Chalet Hotels and Indian Hotels over the fiscals. Moreover, with an asset-heavy model, the company has increased net borrowings to Rs. 26,144.10 million in FY23 from Rs. 22,540.95 million in FY21. We, therefore, recommend an “Avoid” rating for the issue.